|
With the recent unification efforts there has been a significant
level of internet noise questioning the program integrity over the
potential power development that some clever craftsman may be
discovered yet remain to be exploited within the Stock Moto
Standards. Adding to the confusion are a few voices that
either don't really understand the facts or have some personal
motive to maintain a level of fragmentation for their personal
interest.
Lets take a look at a summary of the big picture;
Ask any of the top Moto builders today what the differences are
between a SuperPro Spec CR125 and a Stock Moto configuration.
The answer is 5-6 HP, and a wider powerband. Then ask how
typically how much power drops off from being 1, 2, and 3 jet sizes
too fat?
First where do those 5-6 extra ponies come from?
- Compression - 2.0 + HP.
- Porting - 2.0+ HP
- RS or V-Force Reedcage - 1.0 HP
- ABEC 3 Min Bearings - negligible gain, .1HP @ 12,000 RPM
theoretical.
Thats 5HP so far, what about that last HP? In most cases
from port work that goes beyond a reasonable level of risk for the
majority of karters to run. There gets to be a point where
exhaust port size gets so wide the risk of hanging a ring or
destroying a piston with rapid bridge-wear & scuffing requires
changing - and fitting a piston about every 20 minutes of operation.
The same is true for running compression on the fine edge of
detonation. The air may change just a little bit which is
enough to create catastrophic levels of detonation, so most builders
leave that last HP out for reliability sake. They may save it
for a single annual event where they will be right alongside the
racer to tune for them.
With the above 3 modifications other things are also are
optimized for fractional and systemic value.
Systemic is the key word since without the first 3 mods, the
systemic mods won't provide any positive gains on a Stock Moto.
Systemic mods are;
- RS125 Piston
- RS125 Carb Boot
- Removal of Kick Start boss (Legacy)
- Reed Plenum shaping (Legacy)
- Matching Crankcase junction to ported Cylinder (Legacy)
The effect each of these things contributes to the changes made
rather then being a benefit on it's own with a Stock Moto
configuration. The RS piston isn't allowed so we'll skip over
that.
RS125 Carb Boot comes in a 5° vertical or 5° horizontal
bend. They actually measure about 12° but 5° is how they are
commonly referred to. The CR125 boot has a 30° bend. A
simplistic conclusion would be that the 30° is more restrictive and
therefore the RS125 would be an advantage. It doesn't work
that way any more then say cutting off the rear cone of the pipe
would be better (neglecting the noise). The boot is much more
then just a mount for the carburetor, it controls the flow into the
reeds. This is covered in the
Stock Moto FAQ page at some detail. Coupled with the Stock Reed
Cage the RS125 Boot with stuffers cut off will only reduce power to
less then the CR125 Boot will produce. There is no difference
in power between the 5° Horizontal RS 125 Boot and the 5° Vertical
RS125 Boot. The Horizontal boot doesn't require cutting the
Kick Start Boss where the Vertical Boot does.
Does that seem complicated to understand? Probably not, but
what adds to the disruption and fragmentation is the the intended
mis-representation of facts.
Reed Plenum shaping does affect the powerband more then
anything else. In simple terms, it takes from the bottom end,
below about 10,500 and gives back to the top end. For a Stock
Moto thats limited in the peak RPM efficiency by the ignition curve
the net result is actually a loss on the track. If the motor
were able to run in the 12,800 zone, it would help but only a small
amount.
Matching Crankcase junction to ported Cylinder becomes a
hindrance to power on a Stock Cylinder. The ground area
introduces the protruding edge of the stock Cylinder at the junction
where the Crankcase was ground resulting in a drop of airflow.
The Stock Moto Standards eliminate all the modifications that
enhance Horsepower from creative effort. But what about
powerband and drivability?
Programmable Ignitions are all about shaping the powerband
without any real affect on peak power. They are not allowed on a
Stock Moto. Likewise some port timing stagger can widen the
powerband, again not allowed. In the end, powerband
enhancements are limited by the carburetor, pipe and silencer which
tend to be the most controversial subjects.
Pipe/Silencer has the most profound effect on a motor. As
the Stock Moto Standards have specified the RCE T3, RLV R4, and
RLV6800 the reviews on these are on the
Stock Moto FAQ page .
Carburetors remain an elusive concern. Mostly it's
fear of the unknown that seems to be at the center of it all.
The purpose of the carb is simple; allow as much air through the
bore as possible while keeping a fixed ratio of mixture no matter
what the throttle position is. Looking back at the Pro Moto
years the following carbs have all been proven winners; Mikuni
TMX, Keihn PWK, Dell'Orto VHSB, Kiehn PWM. Depending who
builds the motor is a matter of who prefers a specific carburetor.
Why? Thats what they know how to tune the best. So is
there an advantage to one carb over another? Absolutely.
The best carb is the one you're familiar with tuning.
Take any one of the carbs above you think is the worst and have
it properly tuned. Then take any other carb from above and go
1 full jet size fatter. Which do you really think will be
faster?
The biggest challenge to Stock Moto
today isn't in the tiny differences in power of the motors that may
exist, it's the in the self interest of the people who create
confusion in the program. With the release of the Stock Moto
Standards Unification Program came a hailstorm of mis-information
from a few of the folks in the sport who obviously want to keep
karting locked up in some kind of secret society and fragmented.
Karting has been there and done that for too many years. It's
not the power of the motor that really at question; Its the
power of a few individuals who don't even race thats at question.
2006 offers a bold new approach to the issues through
unification. Unification takes compromise, cooperation and
commitment to what the majority can accomplish together. It
takes a personal responsibility and just a dab of common sense to
see through the myths perpetuated by a few to get the most enjoyment
from this sport that tends to consume us. |